Regulatory Report Logo

Regulatory Alert

EMA Calls on EPA to Ease Cargo Tank Vapor Testing Requirements and Prevent Unnecessary Costs

EMA Regulatory Counsel Contacts:
Jeff Leiter and Jorge Roman
 

Friday, November 13, 2026 – EMA filed comments yesterday with EPA, supporting its proposal to revise cargo tank vapor tightness requirements. EMA urged the agency to finalize the revision promptly and provide enforcement relief so marketers do not incur avoidable testing and repair costs while the rulemaking is completed.

Background

EPA’s 2024 rule set graduated vapor tightness certification limits of 0.5 to 1.25 inches of water pressure drop over five minutes, based on compartment capacity, across three gasoline distribution regulatory programs. The strictest 0.5-inch limit applies to compartments of 2,500 gallons or more, a common configuration in MC-306 and DOT-406 cargo tanks. Following sustained advocacy by EMA, EPA has proposed restoring the 1.0 to 2.5-inch limits that applied before the 2024 rule, which would make 1.0 inch the effective limit for most marketers. The proposal has not yet been finalized.

Why EMA Supports the Revision

EMA supported EPA’s proposed revision and submitted real-world data in support of its comments in three areas:

Fleet characterization. The 2024 rule did not adequately account for MC-306 tanks, which remain in service although production ended in 1995. In an EMA member survey, 42 percent of 65 respondents operate MC-306 tanks. The actual makeup of the fleet matters when EPA assesses whether a standard can be reliably achieved nationwide.

Testing reliability. EPA has acknowledged that Method 27, the required test, has a reported precision of 0.5 inches of water column and that temperature changes can affect readings. At the 2024 rule threshold, normal testing variability can produce an initial failure even when there is no leak. Of six documented tests submitted with EMA’s comments, five would have passed an earlier test run under the 1.0-inch limit, and, in five, the corrective action was additional equalization time rather than repair. The data show the risk of repeated testing and unnecessary repairs; they do not suggest that genuine leaks should go uncorrected.

Cost and downtime. Information supplied through Fueling Minnesota, an EMA member, estimates additional parts, labor, and retesting costs of approximately $364 to $740 per tank at one testing facility. Another testing firm estimated added costs of about $500 per DOT-406 tank and $500 to $1,500 for MC-306 tanks, with some older MC-306 units requiring modifications exceeding $5,000. These are illustrative per-tank estimates, not cumulative costs. Extended testing also takes delivery equipment out of service.

EMA Seeks Prompt Compliance Relief

In its comments, EMA’s requests differ by program:

  • NESHAP. Extend the May 8, 2027 compliance dates for the subparts R and BBBBBB cargo tank requirements by at least one year through a separate, prompt action, and clarify that certifications under the prior limits satisfy federal requirements until the extended date.

  • NSPS. Provide appropriate interim relief. Because enforcement guidance alone does not change binding regulations or control state enforcement, EMA urged legally effective relief where feasible and, if prompt relief is unavailable, a 180-day compliance window following startup.

EMA is not asking EPA to eliminate vapor tightness testing or excuse actual leaks. It seeks continued certification under the previously applicable limits while EPA completes its reconsideration.

What Marketers Should Do Now

Some terminals are already requiring certification at 0.5 inches. Until EPA acts, marketers should:

  • Confirm the standard each loading terminal requires and how it will handle the May 8, 2027 compliance date.

  • Coordinate with tank testers on upcoming recertification schedules.

  • Evaluate substantial equipment modifications in light of current requirements and EPA’s pending action, without deferring necessary repairs or compliance.

  • Monitor EPA’s final rule and any separate action on compliance deadlines.

“EPA has an opportunity to establish a standard that protects air quality while recognizing how cargo tanks are tested and maintained in the field,” said EMA President Rob Underwood. “We appreciate EPA’s willingness to engage with EMA and revisit this issue; hopefully, the agency will act promptly so marketers are not forced to incur avoidable costs while the rule is under reconsideration.”

For additional information, contact EMA Regulatory Counsel Jeff Leiter (jleiter@bmalaw.net) or Jorge Roman (jroman@bmalaw.net).